Skip to content
Left
Continue shopping
Your Order
You have no items in your cart
Promotion
Read more
Each item is hand crafted in Cincinnati, Ohio. Current production time is 5 - 7 business days.
Just In!
Jewelry
Shop By Collection
Inspiration
Custom + Personalized
Couples + Friendship
Wanderlust
Lifestyle Gifts
Movies + TV
Celtic Collection
Shop By Type
Necklaces
Rings
Bracelets
Cuff Links + Tie Bars
Gifts
For Her
For Him
For Mom
Vintage Flatware
Key Chains
Stethoscope Charms
Golf Gifts
Willis + Bella
Leather Collars
Pet Tags By Collection
Adventurers
Green Thumbs
Trendy Pups
Friendly Pups
Magical Creatures
Minis
Wedding Pups
Leather Tags
Shop All
Pet Tags By Shape
Round + Oval
Square + Diamond
Hexagon + Octagon
Collar Slide
Teardrop
Triangle
Nature
Heart
Ear Tag
Leather Tags
Shop All
Extras
Tag Clips
Tag Care
Keychains
Home
/
Magical Creatures
Sort by:
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Submit
New in
Call My Muggles Dog Tag
From
$25.00
Plumage Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$22.00
Feather in the Ferns Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$22.00
Dreamcatcher Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$22.00
New in
Crystal Feather Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$22.00
Therapy Dog Tag
From
$25.00
Medical Needs Dog Tag
From
$25.00
Service Dog Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$25.00
Moth Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$25.00
Dragonfly Hand Stamped Dog Tag
From
$25.00
Musical Pup Hand Stamped Dog Collar Tag
From
$25.00
Ursa Major Hand Stamped Dog Collar Tag
From
$25.00
Floral Crown Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Beacon Moon Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Wizard's Broom Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
2 reviews
From
$26.00
Corner Web Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
From
$26.00
To The Moon Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Eclipse Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
1 review
From
$26.00
Sailing Among the Clouds Pet ID Tag
From
$28.00
Follow the Spiders Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Paper Crane Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Forest Floor Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
3 reviews
From
$26.00
Mermaids Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Pumpkin Patch Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
9 reviews
From
$26.00
Orb Weaver Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Origami Fox Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
From
$26.00
Lunar Phases Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Under The Sea Collar Slide
From
$29.00
Starry Moon Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Cloudy Night Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Mollusca Pet ID Tag
5.0 / 5.0
1 review
From
$26.00
Magical Unicorn Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Filtered Moonlight Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Fairy in the Wood Collar Slide
From
$29.00
Night Sky Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
Halloween Moon Pet ID Tag
From
$26.00
52 results
Left
1
2
Right